Jump to content
BO FB Offtackle Left

TSB Ratings for 2018 QBs

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

When I finally got over the hated Pats winning another SB, I looked back and saw it was an amazing season for QBs. The last time I got the urge to do this was for the 2014 season. I didn't bother to create an overall rating for the order, it's just vaguely in order of who I think is best overall. Don't pay too close attention to the order, just look at the ratings. Questions, comments, critiques, discussion is encouraged. Ratings are MS//PS/PC/APB

 

Oh, I'm back. Maybe.

 

1. Patrick Mahomes K.C. 19//75/75/50

2. Drew Brees N.O. 13//56/81/81

3. Jared Goff LAR. 13//56/75/44

4. Russell Wilson SEA. 25//56/69/44

5. Philip Rivers LAC. 13//44/75/63

6. Andrew Luck IND. 13//56/69/56

7. Tom Brady N.E. 13//56/69/44

8. Deshaun Watson HOU. 31//50/63/63

9. Mitchell Trubisky CHI. 31//63/56/50

10. Dak Prescott DAL. 19//50/63/56

11. Matt Ryan ATL. 13//56/63/69

12. Carson Wentz PHI. 13//69/56/69

and Nick Foles PHI. 13//31/63/56

13. Cam Newton CAR. 31//69/50/56

14. Aaron Rodgers G.B. 19//75/50/38

15. Kirk Cousins MIN. 13//56/56/75

16. Ben Roethlisberger PIT. 13//75/50/50

17. Lamar Jackson BAL. 44//50/44/38

and Joe Flacco BAL. 13//69/31/38

18. Jameis Winston T.B. 19//69/31/44

and Ryan Fitzpatrick T.B. 13//25/50/50

19. Baker Mayfield CLE. 13//63/44/38

20. Derek Carr OAK. 6//63/44/63

21. Ryan Tannehill MIA. 13//50/44/44

22. Eli Manning NYG. 6//50/44/44

23. Marcus Mariota TEN. 25//31/44/63

24. Josh Allen BUF. 38//81/25/25

25. Matthew Stafford DET. 13//75/31/50

26. Nick Mullens S.F. 13//31/44/44

27. Andy Dalton CIN. 13//31/44/38

28. Alex Smith WAS. 13//31/44/38

29. Case Keenum DEN. 13//31/44/38

30. Blake Bortles JAX. 25//50/31/38

31. Sam Darnold NYJ. 13//50/31/31

32. Josh Rosen ARI. 13//44/31/31 

Edited by BO FB Offtackle Left

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok I have a problem with this: the MS with these need to be changed; Lamar Jackson should be 50 MS, Cam should be 44, Pat Mahomes the MVP 31, Russell Wilson really, upgrade to 44, A-Rod, 19 really upgrade to 38 All the QB who have 13 or less MS bump to 25. Baker Mayfield, Deshawn Watson and Dak Prescott 38 apiece.

On ‎3‎/‎8‎/‎2019 at 9:06 PM, BO FB Offtackle Left said:

When I finally got over the hated Pats winning another SB, I looked back and saw it was an amazing season for QBs. The last time I got the urge to do this was for the 2014 season. I didn't bother to create an overall rating for the order, it's just vaguely in order of who I think is best overall. Don't pay too close attention to the order, just look at the ratings. Questions, comments, critiques, discussion is encouraged. Ratings are MS//PS/PC/APB

 

Oh, I'm back. Maybe.

 

1. Patrick Mahomes K.C. 19//75/75/50

2. Drew Brees N.O. 13//56/81/81

3. Jared Goff LAR. 13//56/75/44

4. Russell Wilson SEA. 25//56/69/44

5. Philip Rivers LAC. 13//44/75/63

6. Andrew Luck IND. 13//56/69/56

7. Tom Brady N.E. 13//56/69/44

8. Deshaun Watson HOU. 31//50/63/63

9. Mitchell Trubisky CHI. 31//63/56/50

10. Dak Prescott DAL. 19//50/63/56

11. Matt Ryan ATL. 13//56/63/69

12. Carson Wentz PHI. 13//69/56/69

and Nick Foles PHI. 13//31/63/56

13. Cam Newton CAR. 31//69/50/56

14. Aaron Rodgers G.B. 19//75/50/38

15. Kirk Cousins MIN. 13//56/56/75

16. Ben Roethlisberger PIT. 13//75/50/50

17. Lamar Jackson BAL. 44//50/44/38

and Joe Flacco BAL. 13//69/31/38

18. Jameis Winston T.B. 19//69/31/44

and Ryan Fitzpatrick T.B. 13//25/50/50

19. Baker Mayfield CLE. 13//63/44/38

20. Derek Carr OAK. 6//63/44/63

21. Ryan Tannehill MIA. 13//50/44/44

22. Eli Manning NYG. 6//50/44/44

23. Marcus Mariota TEN. 25//31/44/63

24. Josh Allen BUF. 38//81/25/25

25. Matthew Stafford DET. 13//75/31/50

26. Nick Mullens S.F. 13//31/44/44

27. Andy Dalton CIN. 13//31/44/38

28. Alex Smith WAS. 13//31/44/38

29. Case Keenum DEN. 13//31/44/38

30. Blake Bortles JAX. 25//50/31/38

31. Sam Darnold NYJ. 13//50/31/31

32. Josh Rosen ARI. 13//44/31/31 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

lol a lot of veterans of the game can wreak havoc with a high MS QB. I can't really speak to what might be popular over the last 5 years, but back when I was more active it was understood among most players that QB MS needs to be kept low. I try to follow the original ratings as closely as possible. Most QBs on the original have 13ms, so that's what I follow. If every QB had 25ms or higher, that would be an unplayable rom to me. That's a completely different game. I base it mostly on rushing yards, but I also look at Wins and sacks. In general, it goes like this:

 

Yards - MS

200 - 19

300 - 25

400 - 31

500 - 38

600 - 44

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...