Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
TheFes75

All Time NBA top 5 at Each Position

Recommended Posts

Since there is a lull between the end of Football and the start of Baseball. Basketball is the sport of choice for most folks right now, so I thought I would ask who your NBA All time top 5 at each position are:

Here's Mine:

PG: 1. Magic Johnson 2. Oscar Robertson 3. Isiah Thomas 4. John Stockton 5. Jason Kidd

SG: 1. Michael Jordan 2. Kobe Bryant 3. Jerry West 4. Reggie Miller 5. Clyde Drexler

C: 1. Wilt Chamberlain 2. Kareem Abdul-Jabbar 3. Shaquille O'neal 4. Hakeem Olajuwon 5. Bill Russell

PF: 1. Karl Malone 2. Tim Duncan 3. Larry Bird 4. Charles Barkley 5. Bob Petit

SF: 1. Labron James 2. Elgin Baylor 3. Rick Berry 4. Julius Erving 5. Scottie Pippen

Honorable Mention: PG: Steve Nash SG: Bernard King C: Moses Malone PF: Kevin McHale SF: Dominique Wilkins

Edited by TheFes75

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

PG: Magic Johnson, Bob Cousy, Stephen Curry, Isiah Thomas, Jason Kidd

 

SG: Michael Jordan, Kobe Bryant, Jerry West, George Gervin, Dwyane Wade

 

SF: LeBron James, Larry Bird, Julius Erving, Scottie Pippen, Kevin Durant

 

PF: Tim Duncan, Karl Malone, Bob Pettit, Kevin Garnett,  Dirk Nowitzki/Bob Mcadoo/Barkley

 

C: Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Bill Russell, Wilt Chamberlain, Hakeem Olajuwon, Shaquille O'neal.  

 

Notes: Curry is probably the most controversial, but I'd have to say that from all of the games I've watched of various eras, Curry is up there among the greatest point guards ever. SG looks to be set for the next few years. I can't see anyone challenging those five dudes for a spot in the top 5, now that Harden is a PG (and really has been for the last few years). Although I could argue that the traditional guard positions are dumb anyways. Kobe and MJ were basically PG's in the triangle, as was West later in his career. SF was difficult, since it's not really clear if Bird is a SF or PF, and there's great chance that Kawhi Leonard busts into this list. And you could make the case that Durant is a better player than Erving (skill only, not accolades or perception). PF is extremely heavy on the modern guys. The  PF position was beyond stacked in the 00's. I'm not as high on Barkley as some, since he seemed to be a ball-stopper and played very little defense (Nowitzki was better than him on D once you take away the soft euro stereotype). Anthony Davis has a shot of making this list in the future. Center was pretty much Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and then the other four guys in any order. Center is without a doubt the most competitive position in the all-time list. And unless Joel Embiid stays healthy and can fulfill his vast potential, I can't see any change to this list either. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
33 minutes ago, buck said:

Maravich not on any lists?  just a thought. 

 

He was kind of like the Iverson of his era. Respected by his peers and loved by the fans, but not quite as good as his highlights would make you believe. His flashy play was often detrimental to his team and resulted in a lot of dumb turnovers, and he didn't play defense. As far as SG's go, Gervin is the only guy who plays comparable defense (although from what I've seen, his defense wasn't all that terrible), but his scoring was on whole other level when it came to efficiency, enough of a difference to make up for Maravich's passing skills. 

 

It should be noted that he probably would've ended up a better player if he didn't play for his dad in college. Maravich was allowed to do whatever he wanted, which gave him some terrible habits that haunted him for the rest of his career. I made a video about him a few months ago, and i was disgusted by how Pete-centric that team was. Maravich was like all of the modern AAU stereotypes rolled into a single player and multiplied by a million. 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, PockyCandy said:

PG: Magic Johnson, Bob Cousy, Stephen Curry, Isiah Thomas, Jason Kidd

 

SG: Michael Jordan, Kobe Bryant, Jerry West, George Gervin, Dwyane Wade

 

SF: LeBron James, Larry Bird, Julius Erving, Scottie Pippen, Kevin Durant

 

PF: Tim Duncan, Karl Malone, Bob Pettit, Kevin Garnett,  Dirk Nowitzki/Bob Mcadoo/Barkley

 

C: Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Bill Russell, Wilt Chamberlain, Hakeem Olajuwon, Shaquille O'neal.  

 

Notes: Curry is probably the most controversial, but I'd have to say that from all of the games I've watched of various eras, Curry is up there among the greatest point guards ever. SG looks to be set for the next few years. I can't see anyone challenging those five dudes for a spot in the top 5, now that Harden is a PG (and really has been for the last few years). Although I could argue that the traditional guard positions are dumb anyways. Kobe and MJ were basically PG's in the triangle, as was West later in his career. SF was difficult, since it's not really clear if Bird is a SF or PF, and there's great chance that Kawhi Leonard busts into this list. And you could make the case that Durant is a better player than Erving (skill only, not accolades or perception). PF is extremely heavy on the modern guys. The  PF position was beyond stacked in the 00's. I'm not as high on Barkley as some, since he seemed to be a ball-stopper and played very little defense (Nowitzki was better than him on D once you take away the soft euro stereotype). Anthony Davis has a shot of making this list in the future. Center was pretty much Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and then the other four guys in any order. Center is without a doubt the most competitive position in the all-time list. And unless Joel Embiid stays healthy and can fulfill his vast potential, I can't see any change to this list either. 

I had Cousy originally in my PG list but bumped him for Isiah Thomas.

I like your Gervin pick better than my Drexler pick.

I couldn't put Curry in the mix for point guard considering he has basically had 2 superior years in his career and played second fiddle to Monta Ellis when he first came up.

Dirk in the Power forward list should be a no brainer, but I missed him. Probably because I had Bird as a PF and you had him as a SF.

I think people overlook Elgin Baylor. He was the Michael Jordan/Kobe Bryant of the late 50 and 60's.

Nice list! Good on ya!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, PockyCandy said:

 

Which center would you put Robinson over? Olajuwon?

 

I'm not sure he belongs over any of the others, but he's right there on par with Shaq and Hakeem.  It's really subjective to make a top 5 list.  Nearly impossible, there have been so many great ones.  I like looking on Pro Basketball Reference at the similarity breakdowns.  A top 8 or 10 would be a lot easier to come up with :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

how about two separate NBA "eras" - maybe before/after 3-point era (or like, pre and post 1980)?  that would give a roughly +/-40 years (1946 to present).  makes sense to me.

 

 

 

Edited by buck

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
22 hours ago, meat said:

Will we ever see a dominant back to the basket center again ?

 

That is a great point.  I am guessing we will not, the way the game is played now.  Or it will be a while...  A generational big man like Wilt or Shaq would have to come along again.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
29 minutes ago, rmm1976 said:

 

That is a great point.  I am guessing we will not, the way the game is played now.  Or it will be a while...  A generational big man like Wilt or Shaq would have to come along again.

 

Joel Embiid looks awfully good in the post......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By Baron von Lector
      NBA Showdown 2018
      View File I released this ROM edit for the 25th anniversary of NBA Showdown back in May on my Patreon.com/BaronGaming page.  The rosters and player ratings are based on the end of the 2018 NBA season.
       
      Just like the original, there is player stat tracking, player trades (so you can send Lebron to the Lakers if you want to keep this updated), All Star teams, custom teams, and each team has at least one player with a "marquee" move.
       
      Enjoy!
      Submitter Baron von Lector Submitted 09/27/2018 Category SNES  
    • By Baron von Lector
      I released this ROM edit for the 25th anniversary of NBA Showdown back in May on my Patreon.com/BaronGaming page.  The rosters and player ratings are based on the end of the 2018 NBA season.
       
      Just like the original, there is player stat tracking, player trades (so you can send Lebron to the Lakers if you want to keep this updated), All Star teams, custom teams, and each team has at least one player with a "marquee" move.
       
      Enjoy!
    • By Bolt
      Thought there was a thread, already.
       
      Anyone care to discuss?
      ---------------------------------------
       
      Don't sleep on the Wolves.
       
      That's all I got to say.
       

    • By young_carmello724
      NES Tecmo Basketball 2K15
       
       Sorry so late with joining the Navy and everything but finally got around to it enjoy

      version 1 is normal rosters n teams I speeded up the game a lil but other then that should be as smooth as before
       
      Version 2 is I add in the missing teams Raptors are the 76ers, The grizzlies are magic and the Pelicans are the Hornets 4 the Fans of them team wouldn't be left out like last time
       
      version 1 season is just a roster with me and my friends created players on them
       
      Let me know what you think with feedback and any corrections    
       
      nes NBA 2k15 ver1 .nes
      nes NBA 2k15 ver2 .nes
      nes NBA 2k15 ver1 season .nes
    • By TheFes75
      Has anyone ever tried to edit this ROM for the Sega Genesis.  Even though it didn't keep stats I always liked this version of the game. 

       

      I assume the players have attributes that can be altered since some players hit 3 Pointers better than others and there are 3 different speeds players run at. The game compared to today's games played a little slow but I'm sure that could be altered.

       

      Also each player has a different skill set.  Some players have certain dunks or some only lay the ball up.  The better players like Magic, Chambers, Drexler, D. Robinson, Bird, Isaiah, Jordan and Barkley had signature moves that I assume can be assigned using code in the ROM.  Magic and Jordan would go into a dunk or layup animation from almost anywhere near the basket.

       

      Anyway just wondering if anyone had ever tried to edit this ROM and make a new game.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×